About Our Pizza Shop...

At Mill Street Pizza, we enjoy everyday creating high quality, innovative pizzas. Mill Street Pizza will always stand for freshness, innovation, and crave able flavors in everything we serve.

Most pizza chains use primarily frozen dough, and often skimp on both the quality and quantity of their toppings and ingredients to cut costs. Not at Mill Street Pizza. We knead our dough fresh, from scratch everyday. Our cheese is shredded daily, and combined with 2% mozzarella and provolone in our famous cheese blend. We use only premium meats for our toppings, along with only the finest vegetables which we spread lavishly on every pizza, all the way to the edge of the crust. This commitment to quality and authenticity is why we say we’re “The Best of The Mitt.”

Our Location

We are located in the heart of downtown Vanderbilt in Northern Michigan.

Mill Street Food - YUM!

Some menu items from our kitchen…


What our customers say about us…

Excellent pizza and the most amazing people!

Katelyn Marshall

The food was great. The folks that work there are the great. Pizzas are awesome. Can’t wait to go back. The service was amazing.

Wilma Andrews (May 2016)

Great restaurant and great people!

John Glynn (May 2016)

I just can’t thank Shelly enough for the AWESOME food this past Saturday pizza was amazing for sure.

Kim Lance-Pratt (July 2016)